Tax Expenditures Country Report: France
François Ecalle | 29 November 2024
Fiscal, Discussion Notes | Tags: France, GTED, GTETI, Tax Expenditures
This report is part of a series of country reports on national tax expenditure regimes, published by the Council on Economic Policies (CEP) and the German Institute of Development and Sustainability (IDOS), covering topics such as transparency, the fiscal cost of tax expenditures, benchmarking, evaluations and the political economy of tax expenditure reforms.
Summary
According to the French Ministry of Finance, tax expenditures have a budgetary cost (revenue forgone) equal to 2.9% of GDP, or 6.8% of the total amount of compulsory levies in France in 2023. These derogatory measures take various forms (e.g. exemptions, reduced rates, tax reductions, etc.) and concern most taxes, in particular income tax, corporation tax and value-added tax.
Transparency: tax expenditures are described each year in a report appended to the draft budget for the following year, but the official list is debatable. In effect, these are provisions that derogate from a reference tax standard, the official definition of which is ambiguous.
Complexity: the official list includes 474 tax expenditures that add to the complexity of the French tax system.
Fiscal sustainability: the fiscal cost, or revenue forgone, of tax expenditures is often difficult to estimate, even if its impact on behaviour is not taken into account, and its total cost is therefore uncertain. However, it may be considered too high.
Evaluation issues: there has only been one evaluation of all tax expenditures (in 2011). A small number of tax expenditures have been evaluated since 2011, and these evaluations have often highlighted their low efficiency.
Recommendations: Parliament, the Government and the Court of Auditors have often recommended or announced a systematic evaluation of tax expenditures and the reduction or elimination of the least efficient among them. However, it is politically very difficult to reduce them because of opposition from the people who benefit from them. Tax expenditures have therefore continued to rise in euros but have more or less stabilised as a percentage of GDP since 2014.
Related Posts
Tax Expenditures Country Report: India
Priya Sahu | 7 October 2024Fiscal, Discussion Notes | Tags: GTED, GTETI, India, Tax Expenditures
India's tax landscape is intricate, with various direct and indirect taxes administered by different bodies, such as the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) and the Central Board of Indirect... continue reading
ATI, CEP and IDOS Initiate Community of Practice on Tax Expenditures
Council on Economic Policies | 26 September 2024Fiscal, News | Tags: Tax Expenditures
The Community of Practice (CoP) on Tax Expenditures aspires to leverage the collective expertise of its members to enhance TE governance across ministries of finance, revenue administrations, parliaments, and beyond.... continue reading
Tax Expenditure Country Reports. Unveiling Tax Expenditures at the Country Level
Agustin Redonda and Christian von Haldenwang | 9 July 2024Fiscal, Blog | Tags: GTED, GTETI, Tax Expenditures
As shown by the Global Tax Expenditures Transparency Index (GTETI) the quality and scope of TE reporting is highly heterogeneous across jurisdictions, which makes cross-country comparability even trickier. The new... continue reading
Tax Expenditures Country Report: The Netherlands
Rocus van Opstal | 9 July 2024Fiscal, Discussion Notes | Tags: GTED, GTETI, Tax Expenditures, The Netherlands
Tax expenditures (TEs) in the Netherlands represent a significant portion of government spending, amounting to 15% of GDP in 2022. These provisions include deviations from the standard tax base, rates,... continue reading
Rationalizing the Use of Tax Expenditures – The Role of Parliamentarians
Sofia Berg | 31 January 2024Fiscal, Blog | Tags: Parliaments, Tax Expenditures
The role of parliaments is vital with regard to the monitoring and control of tax expenditures, both as part of the regular budget cycle and ad hoc, if required.... continue reading